It's a terrible thing for a girlfriend to say, but I was excited when you moved to Toronto. We had spent all of our early twenties together, and I wanted desperately to date other people. I promised you over and over that it would be easy to have an open relationship, that all I wanted was the freedom to make out with people at parties. But it was a promise I soon forgot.
I fell madly in love with my roommate. It wasn't a lasting, commited, almost-perfect love (like ours admittedly had been), but an unstoppable tide rushed in by the excitement of how different he was from you. We made love; he fucked me. We had serious discussions; he was hilarious. You sat and listened quietly to my boisterous mouth; he wouldn't shut up for a minute.
I lied to you about how serious it was, how often I slept in his bed, how much he meant to me. I fucked you over.
And I didn't care, because it was so new, so strange, so exciting.
There was a time when I couldn't have told you a white lie because even that small a betrayal would break my heart; I kind of knew from the moment I lied about something so much bigger that we were over.
And yet I pushed it on for one selfish year. I felt incredibly guilty that I wasn't still in love with you, and so lied and lied to myself that I was. Even when it ended with the roommate and I fell for someone else (and it was real this time around), I wouldn't let you go. Once, when we were perfectly happy together, you asked me if I ever felt like breaking up with you, to just do it, rather than drag it on. That is where most of the guilt came from, and why I waited so long. There came a point where I thought, I should have already broken up with you by now if I was going to do it, and so I didn't, over and over again. I kept us going under a cloud of false emotion, lying to you and myself about how I really felt.
This is not to say that there was not always a part of me that was well and truly still in love with you. That there isn't still.
We moved across the country together, spent how many thousands of dollars on plane tickets and shipping our shit. But even back home, back in the room where I lost my virginity to you five years ago, I couldn't make it work. I couldn't summon back old feelings. The lie came tumbling down. It was you who called it,
"This isn't working."
And me who agreed,
"I know, I was just thinking that."
I guess that what I have wanted to say, what I guess I did say but will never be able to repeat often enough to make up for the last year, is that I'm sorry,
I'm sorry,
I'm sorry.
I hope that you hear some small whisper of these words, wherever you are.